Shaykh Abdal-Hakim Murad - Contentions 12
Published by Haseeb January 13th, 2008 in IslamShaykh Abdal Hakim Murad’s latest set of contentions were posted last month. As always, all 12 sets of 100 contentions can be found on Masud Khan’s website. ‘
Here are a few that I particularly liked (and actually understood 
)
4. Nothing is more pessimistic than a naïve belief in progress.
6. Kufr: to see the sun setting, and to do nothing about it.
14. The delight of each worldly pleasure does not last long.
19. Your nafs will never receive exactly what it wants.
27. A busy life makes the Prayer harder; but the Prayer makes a busy life easier.
35. Science is the revelation of order. Faith is the revelation of liberation.
43. Belief in God begins when we cease to believe in ourselves.
46. The saint is the one whose love reminds you of your most recent sin.
57. To be proud of luxury is a sin, but to be proud of disdaining it is worse by far.
58. ‘Moderate Islam’? Do not be an extreme Muslim; be extremely Muslim.
82. He did not say: ‘Guide us to the gay path.’
93. Ibada: remember God to re-member yourself.
98. Practice of the Sunna is at its most pure and uncompromising where it supports cultural diversity.
1. The saint is he whose presence makes you love the Prayer.
2. In the Madeleine
Where the sun don’t shine,
Ancient Rome prevails
Though the gods are more benign.
3. Chauvinism is not a hal, it is a halitosis.
4. Nothing is more pessimistic than a naïve belief in progress.
5. Spouses are traditional in order to be saved by gratitude. Spouses are modern in order to be saved by themselves.
6. Kufr: to see the sun setting, and to do nothing about it.
7. Is the Beast of Divorce coming? Husbands: respect her wants. Wives: respect his dignity.
8. The beginner feels gratitude for the rukhsa in his mind. The advanced seeker feels gratitude for the rukhsa in his heart. The saint never takes the rukhsa at all.
9. Are women ambiguous? It is the muhkamat which are the Mother of the Book.
10. ‘Greed has been severely underestimated and denigrated, unfairly so, in my opinion.’ (Conrad Black)
11. Modernity, at best, is a nostalgia for desire.
12. Liberal Christianity: first goes faith, then goes hope, until charity alone remains.
13. Real fiqh is always a vernacular Islam.
14. The delight of each worldly pleasure does not last long.
15. The longer you wait to claim or forgo your rights, the longer you will wait for friendship.
16. It is only the hungry and unfortunate who may know whether they are good.
17. The believer has faith as his companion, and hope in his destination. The ignorant man has neither, yet he still seeks joy.
18. Self-control makes you a fortress; self-indulgence makes you an animal, either a riding-beast or a target.
19. Your nafs will never receive exactly what it wants.
20. Pain is nine-tenths of desire.
21. If your Islam does not attract pure hearts, it is not Islam.
22. Man is ‘ibara; woman is ishara.
23. Dunya: a little Gentleness, and much Rigour. The fitra: a little Rigour and much Gentleness.
24. Be patient with literalists; but absolutely impatient with their extremists.
25. Lustrate, and you will be illustrious. (Ghurur is only in the ghurra.)
26. Climate change: ‘And We coin similitudes for mankind, that perhaps they may reflect.’
27. A busy life makes the Prayer harder; but the Prayer makes a busy life easier.
28. The nafs is anxiety and agitation. The Spirit is the breath of peace. (‘So give good news to My servants!’)
29. Two names unpronounceable in Edom: Hagar and Muhammad.
30. We need not remain in the dark without dark al-idrak.
31. ‘Islah’ can never mean more than ‘amelioration’.
32. The medievals, seeing the colour of our clothes, would call us all atheists.
33. The preacher should neither lower the price of his goods, nor price Islam out of the market.
34. Kufr: impermanence is a problem. Iman: our anxiety about impermanence is a problem.
35. Science is the revelation of order. Faith is the revelation of liberation.
36. The false Salafi is enraged because Sufism has been taken away from him.
37. Betjeman: summoned by belles.
38. We are divided from the other world by the thinnest of membranes, which we hang with mirrors.
39. Great art is God looking at you. Mediocre art is you looking at God. Demonic art is you looking at yourself alone.
40. Suicide bombing: al-fana’ fi’l-shaytan.
41. Deism is dualism. Occasionalism is the only alternative.
42. Modernity has only footnotes; faith has text as well.
43. Belief in God begins when we cease to believe in ourselves.
44. What are you but a lightly-clothed skeleton?
45. Your bumper sticker is a fish eating a fish; for your Shari‘a fate in the West is to eat fish.
46. The saint is the one whose love reminds you of your most recent sin.
47. An ayah is a wetnurse. When born we suckle, when we die we are weaned.
48. Islam: the real Jesus was unitarian. Christianity: the real Moses was trinitarian.
49. The foundation of Action is Theology. The foundation of Theology is Faith. The foundation of Faith is Action.
50. The foundation of Knowledge is the Body; the foundation of the Body is not Knowledge.
51. Ash‘arism: the turn to the Sunna is a turn towards reason, for the Sunna neglects nothing that is from God.
52. Khawarij are full of hawa.
53. Tasting is always of the Near. Do not, therefore, be veiled from the Transcendent.
54. If you put down your tasbih you will not pick up a rifle safely.
55. Haste is usually the consequence of sloth, not of diligence.
56. Edom produced the modern world of distraction, because it neglected eros and polis.
57. To be proud of luxury is a sin, but to be proud of disdaining it is worse by far.
58. ‘Moderate Islam’? Do not be an extreme Muslim; be extremely Muslim.
59. Dhikr and electricity are deadly rivals.
60. The wife’s vulnerability is not the husband’s strength.
61. You do not rise to Him. He does not descend to you. Rather, what you see, He may unveil as His alone.
62. Your reach towards Him is tiny. His reach towards you has no limit.
63. Love learning, since learning leads to action.
64. Fiqh is the joyful focussing on the moment.
65. Rejoice most highly when the Teacher’s command is hard.
66. Zion is the abuse of Maimonidean Mu‘tazilism.
67. To conform to the Sunna is to ‘conform to God’. Do not think that there is freedom anywhere else.
68. Our finitude is our distance from Him. His infinitude is His closeness to us.
69. The false Salafism: extra Arabia nulla salus.
70. Theology is sharh; Religious Studies is tashrih.
71. No modesty, no sensuality. No sensuality, no knowledge of God.
72. Only the Evil I takes mankind from the minbar to the minibar.
73. The identity-merchant says ‘Un-Islamic’; the Godfearing says: ‘Makruh’ or ‘Haram.’
74. Arius says: Follow the muhkamat!
75. The saint’s belief that he is bound for hell is his halo.
76. Do not use your beard to open people’s ears.
77. Happiness is more important than conforming to the Monoculture.
78. Westernisation? Maqam Rast is ours already.
79. Hû and cry: only by talwin can we endure this age.
80. The false Salafism: it is better to lose angrily than to win calmly.
81. The cross and the décolletage: in hoc signo vinces.
82. He did not say: ‘Guide us to the gay path.’
83. A politician deals with symptoms, a leader deals with causes.
84. Expect only a little. If you impose everything on everyone, you will drive everyone away from everything.
85. We see the world, and think it to be still. But it is coming down fast, all the time, from Heaven. (‘You see the mountains, and think them to be still.’)
86. Rigour of Moses, Ahmad’s mercy,
Beauty of Jesus, heralds all.
In Adam’s heirs no controversy,
Call for change, don’t change the call!
87. In the restaurant of life, the false Salafi can do no more than eat the menu.
88. Da‘wa should start at the point of harmony, not the point of dissonance.
89. Do not trust the Arab who prefers nylon to cotton.
90. The Prayer is rus in urbe.
91. The world survives because one may fall out of love with hatred, but one may never fall out of love with love.
92. Who is a shaykh? One who recognises that his life will soon be over.
93. Ibada: remember God to re-member yourself.
94. If you are threatened by a materialist civilisation, make yourself economically
indispensable.
95. A real aristocrat is a healing for the world.
96. Islam: there is a basis for cumulation. The West: there is only cumulation.
97. ‘Down to Gehenna, or up to the Throne,
He travels the fastest who travels alone.’ (Kipling)
98. Practice of the Sunna is at its most pure and uncompromising where it supports cultural diversity.
99. Rafidism: the first Muslim conspiracy theory.
100. You cannot arrive by making an effort, but you cannot arrive without making an effort.
TJ is brilliant…ppl should really check out his articles on the masud site if they haven’t
Reading this I felt that a small amount of it is common sense and the rest of it dangerously stupid unphilosophical assumptions that encourages ignorance. I feel that number 4 in the list, at the top of Haseebs list of 13 favorites, is a perfect example:
4. Nothing is more pessimistic than a naïve belief in progress.
I mean how backward do you want to get? What’s wrong with positive progress and progress in many varied and in fields that are beneficial to humanities health and sanity. I do understand that Humanity has made many mistakes, but it has made many many great changes to adapt it’s self to push our understanding of everything from ourselves to everything else in the universe to help to improve us and remove the ignorance that created the mistakes made in the first place. Science allowed us to understand more about everything, including ourselves inside and out, than religion or romantic semantic verse ever has or will do. Which leads me on to:
35. Science is the revelation of order. Faith is the revelation of liberation.
Faith in Science and ourselves, perhaps? Again this shit feeds it’s self:
43. Belief in God begins when we cease to believe in ourselves.
“Cop-out” is all I have to say to number 43. Wouldn’t it be nice have to have all moral decisions taken out of our hands. What I mean is; Is it not ridiculous to not believe that you and you alone are the master of your own destiny? Weakness is to believe in a god. Be strong, be yourself, be uncompromisingly you, be better than you. Believe you are not stupid, question everything, question your beliefs. Act as you wish others to act to you. Be an example to the world of who you are. Be remembered for only the good things in you. Believe in yourself and watch the world bloom. Believe in this world and this world alone and we may together, through science and pure philosophy, fix this world that ignorance in many forms has brought it to the brink of it’s destruction.
I hope I have not offended people with my comments, but I feel that these “Shaykh Abdal Hakim Murad’s” latest set of contentions need to be put in perspective of what they are in my most humble opinion: Nothing but romantic semantics.