June 2007
S M T W T F S
« May   Jul »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930











MECCA Hatemail

Here is a recent post by my good friend Saleem, who is a board member and instructor for MECCA (Muslim Education & Converts Center of America). It’s a copy of a recent hateful message sent to MECCA, along with a response from the MECCA President.

This is the letter we received, unedited:

American as apple pie?

Would you describe stoning to death a 17 year old woman as American as apple pie?

You people are pigs. This is not a religion, is it a form of barbarism.

Get out of our country, you are not welcome here.

I am an American woman and your culture is anathema to our rights. The men in your culture are barbaric, hairy, stupid sexist pigs. And that women in America SHARE POWER with me is AMERICAN AS APPLE PIE. SO GET OUT.

Get the next plane out of our country. You do not belong here with your sexist views and perspectives on women. And your religion is frightening to us all. Who will you blow up or stone to death next????

And here is Brother Tom’s response:

Dear ———,

Your email was refreshing. Thank you. I always enjoy hearing the honest, uncensored comments from people like you who have been misled to believe that “the muslims” are barbarians. To answer your question, I would not describe stoning a 17 year old girl to death as “American as apple pie.” Why would you ask?

Would you, as an American woman, like to be told that “you people are pigs” and to “get out of our country, you are not welcome here?” I, as an American man, do not appreciate being spoken to in such a manner. Perhaps you have heard of the golden rule - do unto others as you would have others do unto you? Try it sometime.

Now that you have vented your anger about atrocities commited by some Muslims somewhere by sending me a nasty email, please take a moment to examine your views. If you are a white Christian, would you want to be judged by the actions of the Ku Klux Klan or Timothy McVeigh or the genocidal war criminals among the Bosnian Serbs? I think not. Likewise, we Muslims do not like being judged for the crimes committed by fanatical Muslims or jihadis. Have you ever heard of guilt by association? It is un-American.

Also, your comment that Muslim men are “barbaric, hairy, stupid sexist pigs” is nothing more than naked bigotry. Bigotry is no longer American as apple pie- although it used to be. By the way, we Muslim Americans are not getting on any planes and leaving our country - because it is OUR country too. There is a little bit in the Bill of Rights known as the Establishment Clause. It guarantees the freedom of religion. So I get to be Muslim, and you don’t have to be scared of me because I cannot force you to worship as I do. But you have to let me worship as I choose, and you can’t kick me out of the country, or deny me any equal rights under the law because of my religion. That is American as apple pie.

You ask “who will you blow up or stone to death next?” This question implies that I have already blown someone up, or stoned someone to death. You must have me confused with somebody else. I have never even been in a fistfight.

I hope you can find it in your heart to shed the hatred you feel for people who have committed no wrong other than worshiping God as Muslims. Anyway, you will need to get used having us hairy, stupid guys around, because we’re not going anywhere. If it’s too upseting for you, maybe you should consider moving somewhere else. I hear there are almost no Muslims in Antarctica. (just joking!).

I do not mean to give you a hard time, but your email really demanded a response. Don’t judge all Muslims by the actions of a few.

May God bless you.
Tom Wilentz

Click here to read the entire post on Saleem’s Blog.


8 Responses to “MECCA Hatemail”

  1. 1 saad omar from: Australia auyour flag

    excellent response tom…

  2. 2 norah from: France fryour flag

    I hope she re-thinks about what she wrote and compares that with toms response and hopefully works it out logistically.

  3. 3 LondonMuslim from: Great Britain (UK) gbyour flag

    Brilliant response!!!! I love how you made the point that it wouldn’t be as “American as Apple Pie” to throw muslims out =P, and how bigotry isn’t American “any more”

    I’m inspired!

  4. 4 IBO from: United States usyour flag

    excellent response indeed

  5. 5 nayyer from: United States usyour flag

    salaamoalekum,
    mashaAllah, it really takes a level-headed and mature mind to calmly respond to such kinda words. may Allah (SWT) bless brother Tom

  6. 6 Mujahideen Ryder from: United States usyour flag

    MashaAllah! Tom is the man!

  7. 7 Addy from: Australia auyour flag

    I wonder if the native indians of America had the chance to say “Get out of our country, you are not welcome here.” before they were mass murdered? I wonder if the Africans brought into America as slaves had a voice to say “You people are pigs. This is not a religion, is it a form of barbarism.” But as always, its always double standards applied. The response is great and I really hope she studies more about Islam and finds it to be the beautiful religion like so many American women who reverted to Islam have! Nice, isnt it, to see such a trend in the face of such accusations? It goes on to reveal the truth of the matter! :)

  8. 8 Ibraheem from: Great Britain (UK) gbyour flag

    The funny thing is that apple pie is not American…

Leave a Reply